I’m a Climate Reality Leader, and I’m packing a presentation

Last week, I returned from the Climate Reality Project Leadership Corps training in Denver, Colorado. Suffice to say, I wasn’t astonished to learn the Earth is warming due to the increase in CO2 emissions from human activity. I’ve been aware of the science investigating this phenomenon for most of my adult life and have become increasingly worried by the news that climate change is happening at a much faster rate than previous models predicted, and that its effects were turning out to be even worse than previously thought.

But my concerns about climate change has only been exceeded by my frustration with an unrelenting science denial machine that’s been operating since the 1950’s. Over the years, I’ve won some arguments, but I’ve also lost some friends. I needed a better way to discuss climate change without alienating people. I knew that the Climate Reality Project, led by Vice President Al Gore, offered training, and that I really should apply for training should the opportunity arise.

And then the 2016 election was won by the candidate who insists climate change is a hoax, facts be damned.

Forget winning the argument, it was time to learn how to win the conversation, so off to Denver I went. Here are some takeaways from my trip.

The weather is weird everywhere, even in Denver

Though I’ve flown into Denver International Airport countless times, this was the first time I’ve ever actually been to the city of Denver itself. I was treated to a lovely view of the Rocky Mountains, which was utterly devoid of snow.

The Rocky Mountains, as seen from my hotel room in Denver, March 1st 2017. Note the lack of snow.

It turns out, the greater Denver area has been largely devoid of snow this winter. What’s more, temperatures reached the high 60’s and even low 70’s during the day. This is a problem, considering that early March is supposed to be Colorado’s peak snow season.

We’re gonna win this

Our training room in the Colorado Convention Center. 1001 Climate Reality trainees ready to get after it.

On the first day of training, Vice President Gore delivered his full presentation titled The Climate Crisis and its Solutions. It’s a fitting title, since there are, in fact, real ways to solve the climate crisis. I’ll save the details of the talk for later, but Gore’s overall message was much more hopeful and optimistic than I was expecting.

Vice President Al Gore discussing the climate crisis as a public movement that will ultimately be won.

Gore compared the climate movement to other social movements such as civil rights and marriage equality. Once the argument comes down to a simple  choice between right and wrong, the answer is a foregone conclusion.

Make no mistake, some of the damage caused by catastrophic climate destabilization (my term) will not be undone. And we’re heading for the worst of the irreversible tipping points.  But momentum towards addressing the climate crisis is building, even as time to address the worst of its effects is running out.

The train is leaving the station, but you can still jump on

Coal is getting killed by natural gas, not by regulations. And oil & natural gas are getting crushed by wind and solar. That’s not to say we should be thrilled to see coal miners, frackers, and oil workers out of a job. That would be bad for our economy, bad for society as a whole, and certainly a horrible situation for the families affected.

But it doesn’t have to be doom and gloom for those workers and their families. A recent Harvard Business Review study found that these workers could be retrained for a paltry $180 million to $1.8 billion (depending on best and worst-case scenarios) for related jobs in the solar industry for an average 11% increase in pay. Think about that for a moment. About 150,000 workers could be retrained for better paying clean jobs for less than the cost of a single B-2 bomber. And these jobs won’t increase the rates of black lung disease, which are putting a burden on our expensive health care system.

Story ≫ Science

Although the science of climate change is well-known and long settled, it’s also become increasingly apparent that facts don’t change most people’s minds. Everyone is human and clings to their preferred narrative, especially when that narrative permits people to go about their business and not worry about the consequences.

So presenting the science isn’t enough. There needs to be a personal story to help people understand the problem on a real human scale. That’s why we were given some pro tips on body language and personal storytelling by Ngiste Abebe, co-founder and COO of Aulenor Consulting. There was a lot packed into her presentation and it’s clearly something I’ll need to do some more research on to become a better presenter as well as just better at ordinary conversations.

Al Gore in An Inconvenient Sequel: Truth to Power (2017). Credit: Participant Media

We were treated to a sneak peek of the upcoming follow-up to 2005’s An Inconvenient Truth, fittingly titled An Inconvenient Sequel: Truth to Power (alas, we weren’t permitted to take pictures). The clip was followed by a discussion with Al Gore, co-director John Shenk, and co-producer Diane Weyermann of Participant Media (the sequel features two directors and two producers for extra awesomeness).

It was a fascinating discussion of what makes a good story and on finding the right blend of science and narrative. Perhaps the biggest revelation was that at the end of the 2005 film, the only call to action available at the time was for people to change their light bulbs. Now there’s a lot more people can do.

The people were awesome, but my mentor was the awesome-est

I was told by more than one staff member that a lot more people came to this training than was expected. Evidently, the election galvanized a lot of people into showing up, and they brought their A-game.

I met people from exotic places such as Malaysia, India, Pakistan, Madagascar, Indonesia, Peru, Italy, New Jersey, and Maryland (in fact, two at my table were fellow Marylanders, one who’s probably a 20-minute drive from my home). Their ages ranged from 6 to 84, and all of them were motivated and eager to learn. Each of our tables was shepherded by a Climate Mentor, a volunteer who’s been active in Climate Reality for a while. While I was impressed by the mentors, there’s not a question in my mind that I had the best.

Me and Rocio Criales Ananos, my mentor at Climate Reality. She’s gangsta.

Rocio Criales Ananos had a successful business in her home town in Peru, but decided that leaving the world a little more habitable for her son and future generations would be a better use of her time on Earth. She became a Climate Reality Leader in 2014 and has been killing it ever since. Not only has she given many, many presentations, she organized her own local 24 Hours of Reality event which included a concert, and was recognized as one of the top Climate Mentors by Al Gore during his opening remarks.

Rocio was amazing. Anything we needed, she was there. As was her 12-year old son, Orion, whom I had the pleasure of meeting. Orion was one of many young people at the training and Rocio has every right in the world to be proud of him.

Rocio is good.
Rocio is kind.
Rocio is gangsta.
Be like Rocio.

Climate Reality Leaders from Pakistán, USA, Colombia, Peru, Indonesia, Belize, and Paraguay. Better known as Table 29. Credit: Rocio Criales Ananos

Next steps: get out there and get after it

None of this would have been possible without the help from my generous GoFundMe contributors. Thanks to you, I have a way to present on the topic and help raise awareness. There’s a lot of work left to do, but I’m grateful for the opportunity to do it.

License to present: my Climate Reality bonna-fides

I have access to the Climate Reality slides and am cleared to give the Climate Crisis and its Solutions presentation to the public. Now I gotta schedule some presentations, write a letter to the Editor, talk to some elected officials, and tell a story.

If you’d like to have a presentation given to your group, either in person or online, I’d be more than happy to help. If I can’t give the presentation, I can certainly help you find a local Climate Reality Leader who can. Drop me a line and let’s talk. We have a lot of work to do and a short time to do it.

Eugene Cernan

I was born just in time to say that I am a child of the Apollo era (except for arriving too late for Apollo 11, but I really don’t mind as it beats the alternative). Among my very early memories are those of the tail end of the program, and ultimately the very end with Apollo 17 in 1972 (1)Sure there was Apollo-Soyuz but it was more of a coda than an end.

That mission was commanded by Eugene Cernan, Captain, USN. Cernan was pilot of Gemini 9, Lunar Module pilot of Apollo X (which got him to within 47,000 feet of the lunar surface), and commander of Apollo 17, which closed the remaining 47,000 feet. I found this clip on YouTube which summarized Cernan’s last mission:

Until Apollo 17, every NASA astronaut was a current or former military test pilot. But this final mission included NASA’s first scientist-astronaut, Harrison “Jack” Schmidtt, a geologist. I love the genuine excitement in Schmidtt and Cernan’s voices as they find the orange rocks they were hoping to find in the Taurus–Littrow valley.

Capt Gene Cernan, USN, in the Taurus–Littrow valley, Moon. December, 1972. Credit: NASA:

“We leave as we came, and, God willing, we shall return, with peace and hope for all mankind.” — Cernan’s closing words on leaving the moon at the end of Apollo 17

Eugene Cernan was the last man to ever walk on the Moon; the last human being to ever walk on another world. And now he has left this world one final time.

   [ + ]

1. Sure there was Apollo-Soyuz but it was more of a coda than an end

A Sky of Fire Ice

Ice in the sky. Photo taken and provided by Joshua Thomas. Taken in Red River, NM the morning of January 9, 2015.
Ice in the sky. Taken in Red River, NM the morning of January 9, 2015. Credit: Joshua Thomas

Most people hate winter, but for those of us who watch the sky, there’s no better time to witness some of nature’s most dazzling optical displays, like the one you see here.

The image was taken by Joshua Thomas in Red River, New Mexico on January 9, 2015, at where I am guessing might be the Red River Ski resort. The arcs and halos are light passing through ice crystals, which act like tiny prisms of varying shapes. They refract and reflecting light rays into the patterns seen here. More often than not, viewing conditions only show perhaps just one or two of these patterns, but Joshua’s photo shows several rare patterns happening all at once.

Let me stipulate that I’m hardly an expert at this but with the help of the atmospheric optics site I’ve been able to identify – or at least make an educated guess – at some of these arcs. Let’s take them one at a time.

At the center is the Sun, washed out in this view., though perhaps there is a Sun Pillar formed by light reflecting off small, plate-like crystals. It is immediately surrounded by the 22° halo. These halos are fairly common, and you may have noticed them surrounding the full moon on a winter’s night. If you look closely at the photo, you’ll notice that there is a reddish color on the inside and a bluish color toward the outside. This is exactly what you’d expect to see if the light were being refracted by the ice crystals.

To the left and right of the Sun are Parhelia, or sundogs. We only see the right sundog in this photo, the left being obscured by the mountain range. Typically, these are teardrop-shaped, but sometimes they extend to form long streamers called Parhelic Circles. It looks like we have a nice Parhelic Circle going horizontally to the right. I imagine there would be one stretching outward from the left if the mountain wasn’t in the way. These circles run parallel to the horizon and can even wrap 360° around the horizon if you have a clear enough view!!

The gull wing-shaped structure is called the Tangent Arc which, as its name implies, is just grazing the 22° halo. Notice that the wingtips are connected by a “capping” arc, called the Parry Arc.

Piercing the Perry arc is a “V”-shaped sunvex Perry Arc, which is a very rare phenomenon. Sunvex Perry Arcs are caused by light passing through hexagonal column ice crystals in high and cold cirrus cloud. These ice crystals are suspended nearly perfectly horizontal in the sky,  as if that weren’t cool enough.

Surrounding the structures is what appears to be a giant rainbow. At first, I assumed this was the 46° halo, because it appears circular and seems to be about 46° across. But I learned that 46° halos are rare and typically very dim.  Now I’m thinking that this must in fact be a Supralateral Arc, which are brighter than 46° halos and show up at the same location. Supralateral Arcs are sometimes accompanied by Infralateral arcs, and at first I thought that may be what see poking up from the treetops on the left from the edge of the arc on the right at a 45° angle from the Parhelic Circle. But on further inspection, I’m not convinced that’s really what those are. Still stumped on this.

By way of illustrating my guesses, I color-coded the different arcs according to the types I think they are. Please let me know if I got any of them wrong!sky optics